The stalling ground

Day one of this year’s IWC meeting lasted a scant 2 hours, including the opening entertainment and a long coffee break – at least, the part of it that was open to media and NGOs.  The rest of the day was spent behind closed doors, in private discussions intended to bring the parties to a point where they agreed enough about fundamental issues to risk coming back into open session again.  Not only are today’s meetings private, tomorrow’s will be too.  The next time the plenary meets will be on Wednesday morning.  By then, if the chairman gets his way, the die will have been cast.

There is an unreal air about the proceedings here in Agadir.  Everything of substance is happening behind closed doors, with very little by way of news coming out.  Most of those on the outside have nothing to do except chat, interview each other and take long lunches.  One might think there was nothing going on, and some attendees are more than a little miffed at coming all this way to occupy an expensive seat they barely had time to occupy before being told to leave.  Some of the NGOs felt so short changed at being hustled out of the room they felt like staging a sit in, which after the fact seemed like a good idea, as it would have been the media hit of the day.

As things turned out, about the only things for the media to grasp onto were a joint statement by Pew, WWF and Greenpeace, expressing support for a deal that ended whaling in the Antarctic, among other bottom line demands (Greenpeace was the news) and a tiny demo that happened briefly this morning, before the opening.  A small group of protesters held signs at the entrance to the venue, declaring Japan’s “research” whaling fake, pleading for the lives of babies in Australia’s whale nursery, now threatened by oil & gas development, and demanding an end to the slaughter of whales and dolphins.   A Sea Shepherd banner served as a reminder of an absent protester.   Japanese delegates hurried past while their Canadian compatriot paused briefly to offer abuse.  There were no arrests, and the demo soon ended peacefully.   Dozens of police and military guarded the site, and paddy wagons patrolled back and forth.  The demo soon over, it was on to business as usual, except that this morning really wasn’t usual.

The Chairman, Antigua & Barbuda’s Commissioner Anthony Livingstone, provided the audience with a lengthy explanation of the process that has been underway, intermittently for the past 2 years, and intensively for the past 2 weeks.  He called on everyone to work hard and come up with a deal. Then he closed the session and the room was cleared.  It’s unclear why Chairman Livingstone thinks that 2 more days of discussions behind closed doors, with even more parties involved than hitherto, might produce the outcome he seeks, but he’s going for it.  Given the flak he’s having to take over Japan paying his hotel bill, possibly he feels more comfortable in a private room.

Tomorrow, the rumour mill will be at work.  We may even hear something like news.

Posted by Paul Spong

Some links to current stories:




Once more unto the breach

There’s a déjà vu quality to the scene that surrounds the days before the opening of this year’s meeting of the International Whaling Commission (IWC).   It happens to be in Agadir, Morocco, and like other venues of late, a casino is next door, so a rolling of the dice analogy comes easily to mind.  Both “sides” are intensely involved in pre-meeting discussions and negotiations, from which media witnesses have been entirely excluded.   NGOs have been invited to some of the sessions, and at times a few have even been allowed to voice brief opinions, but little in the way of clarity about what is really happening has emerged.  The “deal” which would see the renewal of legally sanctioned commercial whaling and effectively end the moratorium, that took effect in 1986, is apparently still very much in play. Leading the effort to achieve the whaling equivalent of “peace in our time” are New Zealand and the USA.  Both are surprising participants, given that Candidate for President Obama made an unqualified promise to strengthen the moratorium on commercial whaling, and that New Zealand has long been in the forefront of efforts to bring an end to the dark days of the whaling era.

As a New Zealander who has spend much of his life abroad, I have never been more proud of my home country than in meetings of the IWC, when New Zealand’s impassioned defence of whales, and opposition to their wanton slaughter, was a lynchpin of the hope that people around the world held for their future – that whales will soon see a day in which they no longer face the threat of bloody death at the hands of men who see them only as objects to destroy, render and sell.  I recall the entire New Zealand delegation standing to deliver a vigorous Haka as part of their plea, and the words used by the New Zealand Commissioner in commenting on the IWC’s search for direction: “What the IWC needs is a moral compass”.  It never occurred to me that New Zealand would desert this high ground on the field that is no less than a battle for life on our planet.  But it has.

In becoming active partners in a process that will shred the environmental movement’s crowning accomplishment, New Zealand and the USA have redrawn the line between defenders and exploiters of whales.  Sadly, both nations now stand on the side of the whalers, apparently even agreeing to the slaughter of whales for profit within the Southern Ocean Whale Sanctuary.  Yes, as the proponents of the deal claim, the draft agreement does reduce the number of whales that will be slaughtered over the next 10 years, but the key element and the one that Japan wants so badly, is that the killing will be legal.  Japan’s whalers will no longer have to hide their ugly business behind “research” placards and propaganda; they will no longer be pirates on the high seas.

In the background, research into the development of new products made from whales, including medicines, cosmetics, and feed for farmed fish goes on quietly, with dozens of new patents granted or being applied for.  See the truly grim picture of this future for whales at:

How can it be, one might ask, that Japan’s utterly irresponsible behaviour merits such a reward?  Giving it the prize it has sought for so long is akin to a school bully being awarded a badge of merit, out of fear, a senseless act fraught with unknown consequences.  What might that bully become?

As a New Zealander, I hang my head in shame, as must many of my country folk, and I am quite sure that many Americans feel ashamed of their leadership too.  Collectively experiencing a sense of betrayal, we now rely on the hope that Australia and other staunch defenders of whales will rally enough support for the cause of justice in our world’s oceans, to turn back the tide.  In Agadir, Morocco, on the shores of a sparkling blue Atlantic Ocean, once again, the battle is about to be joined.

“Save the whales, save the earth” is an old slogan, but it has never had more meaning than today.

We stand on the brink of a precipice.  Do we fall, or step back?

By Paul Spong

June 20 2010

Some links to additional information, news stories, videos, and suggestions for action: (Australia/New Zealand PSA) (USA PSA) (Japan’s vote buying exposed) (Japanese whistleblower story) (bribery denial story)’s_whale_vote_buying_undermining_the_iwc.php

​ (Avaaz petition has more than 900,000 names) (WDCS petition) (WDCS campaign)

A crucial meeting of the International Whaling Commission

This year’s meeting of the International Whaling Commission (IWC) is shaping up as the most crucial in the history of the organisation, which was formed in 1946, and tasked with the role of protecting both whales and the whaling industry.  In the years since 1946, the Commission has seen some species of great whales pushed to the brink of biological extinction, and others into “commercial” extinction, while the whaling industry, once so mighty, faded and almost died.  In 1982, the IWC decided to impose an indefinite moratorium on commercial whaling, which has been helpful to the nascent recovery of some critically endangered species and populations.   The full restoration of the role of whales in ocean ecosystems is still a long way off, and may never happen, but the signs of progress are encouraging.  It comes as a shock, therefore, to realise that the whaling moratorium, which came as a beacon of hope for the environmental movement, and was so difficult to achieve, is now itself endangered.  In Adagdir, Morocco, members of the IWC are now gathering, to consider allowing commercial whaling to resume, including in the Antarctic Whale Sanctuary.  There is a significant probability that the Commission will agree.  This blog will follow events as they unfold.